Ubuntu USB NTFS filesystem bugs
Seeing as I need to transfer >4GB files between computers running GNU+Linux as well as Mac and Windows I'm stuck with the only option of NTFS filesystem on that USB stick. The problem is how poor Ubuntu support is (well it even has support now, so things have moved on a lot in the last few years).
Windows causes a lot of problems, because it does not unmount filesystems which are not in use, so if a friend pulls out hte USB stick without going through the "Safely Remove" (or the duplicate "Edject" menu item on Vista) Ubuntu will refuse to mount it. With an error as follows:

How Ubuntu developers expect average users to achieve this I have no idea. Ubuntu should fix the process to be simple and clear as follows:
- External drive icons are visible on Desktop.
- If one fails to mount due to this NTFS flag, the user should be prompted to check it and then mount.
- Context menu on each drive icon should offer "Safely remove" as well as "Scan for errors" and "Format".
p.s. Also Ubuntu shouldn't copy files and directories with excluded Windows characters, like ":", because the user will only arrive at their friend's house and find that their friend who is stuck using Windows can't access the files.
p.p.s. Windows no-longer unmounts drives when shutting down, so if you take out your USB stick formatted NTFS from a machine that is off you will find it also won't mount on Ubuntu.
2 Comments:
This is already fixed in 9.04.
Ubuntu should release the fix for 8.04, it's meant to be LTS. 9.04 isn't out! and wont be for some time.
The best strategy for Ubuntu is not to release with such glaring QA faults in the first instance though.
Post a Comment
<< Home